I do not remember how I came to know that the song that I inherently liked – Jaa Tum se Nahin Bolun Kanhaiyaa – Manna Dey and Lata Mangeshkar, Shaliendra, Salil Chaudhary (Is it because each of the apparently known ingredients of the creation also happen to be my inherent favorites, that I liked this song? – I really do not know. But like I do.)- is based on a variant of classical Raag [Taraanaa in Raag Hansdhwani].
A few days back, I wondered what more can we find out about this song or Raag! And , hence this post……..
First and foremost, let us listen to the melody:
Parivar – Ja Tose Nahin Boloon
This is really a very good example of Hamsadhwani. The basic theme of this piece was “borrowed” from “Vatapi Ganapathim”, which is a traditional Carnatic piece from Dixitar [comment @ http://chandrakantha.com/raga_raag/film_song_raga/hamsadhwani.shtml]
Next, in the list to listen is the basis of this song – as I know – the Taraanaa in Hamsadhwani. And what a coincidence – the two pieces that I had landed upon were rendered by Ustaad Amir Khan Saa’b and Begum Parveen Sultana, again my favorites when it come my pleasures of listening Indian Classical Music.
Here they are:
“Ustad Amir Khan tarana Raag Hamsadwani – awesome.flv”
Ustad Shahid Parvez Khan – pays homage to the great Ustad Amir Khan by playing his famous tarana in Raag Hansadhwani. This video was filmed during the closing moments of a shibir hosted by the SPK Academy of Music. Raag Hansadhwani
Raga Hamsadhwani – Tarana – Parveen Sultana – Taken from: Sadabahar Hamsadhwani Music Today – Living Media India Ltd, Jan 2006
Here is an alternative version too:
Before we take a deeper plunge in the classical terrain, let us visit what we can find in ‘Other Film Songs’ variety.
And I have a surprise on my hand:
Visit to site http://chandrakantha.com/raga_raag/film_song_raga/hamsadhwani.shtml shows another great favourite of mine – O Chaand Jahaan Woh Jaaye – Lata and Asha, Rajendra Krishna, C. Ramchandra composed in Raag Hamsadhwani in Tal Kaherva:
This site also quotes one more non-filmy Meera Bhajan, rendered by Lata, which is compsed by Hridyanaath Mangeshkar
Karam Ki Gati Nyari http://youtu.be/wnGhZHhsDwg
We would continue this as series of posts……
5 thoughts on “Hamsadhawani – An amateur’s search for ‘Something More’ about his favorite film song”
A beautiful post!
Jaa Tose is one of my favrts!
Thanks for your very appreciative feelings.
Both the Hindi film songs are my All Time Favorites.
Being musically illiterate, I can make neither head, nor tail of the technicalities of the raag. But ‘jaa tose’ is a real classic.The three posts cover so many pieces in this raag! When I was at Lucknow, I heard one of our senior’s father (a famous classical Carnatic vocalist) sing ‘vatapi ganapathim’, but did not realize that this was the same raag as ‘jaa tose’ in spite of the close resemblance. It struck me only on reading this post.
Very nice! 🙂